Spider-Man: Brand New Day Ranked — Where Tom Holland's Boldest Movie Really Lands
Spider-Man: Brand New Day just hit theaters, and fans want to know where it lands. Here's every Spider-Man movie ranked, plus a tool to build your own list.
Hayden 5 min read
Why We Can't Stop Ranking Spider-Man Movies
There's something different about Spider-Man compared to other superheroes. Most of us have watched at least three different actors put on the mask, which means most of us have also quietly picked a favorite — and defended it in group chats more times than we'd like to admit. Every time a new film drops, that old argument reopens. With three live-action Spider-Men and two award-winning animated films now competing for the top spot, ranking them isn't just a fun exercise. It's how fans figure out what actually mattered to them about this character in the first place.
From Homecoming to Brand New Day: Where Tom Holland's Spider-Man Movies Really Rank
If you've followed tom holland spider-man movies from the beginning, you already know his arc has been unusually personal. Homecoming introduced a Peter Parker who felt like an actual teenager. Far From Home let him grieve while still cracking jokes. No Way Home brought back two other Spider-Men and ended with a devastating reset: the world forgot Peter Parker ever existed.
Brand New Day picks up from exactly that wound. Peter is now working alone, watching MJ and Ned build a life at MIT without him, and slowly losing his grip while his powers start behaving in ways he can't control. Critics have described the film as noticeably darker and more grown-up than anything in this era before it, closer in tone to a street-level crime story than a typical blockbuster. That shift in tone is exactly why so many fans are placing it near the top of the Holland trilogy-plus-one.
Here's a rough breakdown if you're building your own tier list:
- S-Tier: Spider-Man 2 (2004), Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (2023),
- A-Tier: Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026), Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018)
- B-Tier: Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019), The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014),The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)
- C-Tier: Spider-Man 3 (2007)
- D-Tier: Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021), Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017)
Your own order will probably look different, and that's the entire point.
Andrew Garfield vs Tom Holland: Which Era Actually Wins?
No conversation about ranking these films is complete without the andrew garfield vs tom holland debate. Garfield's two outings leaned into a scrappier, more romantic version of Peter — his chemistry with Emma Stone still gets brought up constantly, even years later. Holland's run, by contrast, has always felt more like a coming-of-age story stretched across multiple movies, culminating in the isolation and darker themes of Brand New Day.
Neither answer is wrong. If you loved the raw emotional swings of The Amazing Spider-Man, Garfield probably sits higher on your list. If you've been with Holland since he was a nervous kid in Civil War, watching him carry the weight of Brand New Day likely hits harder. This is exactly the kind of personal, no-wrong-answer question that a tier list is built for — you can literally drag each movie into the row that matches how you feel, instead of arguing about it in a comment section.
If you want to settle the debate for yourself instead of just reading about it, you can build your own Spider-Man movies tier list right now and see exactly where every film lands for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Spider-Man: Brand New Day connected to No Way Home? Yes. The story picks up directly after the spell that erased Peter Parker from everyone's memory, so watching No Way Home first will make Brand New Day hit much harder emotionally.
Who stars in Spider-Man: Brand New Day? Tom Holland returns as Peter Parker, alongside Zendaya, Sadie Sink, Jacob Batalon, Jon Bernthal, and Mark Ruffalo, under director Destin Daniel Cretton.
Is Brand New Day better than No Way Home? It depends what you're looking for. No Way Home leans into spectacle and nostalgia; Brand New Day leans into isolation and a darker, more personal tone. Many fans rank them close together for very different reasons.
Where should Brand New Day sit in a Spider-Man tier list? Most early reactions place it in the upper half of the ranking, though exactly how high depends on whether you value scale or emotional depth more.
Final Takeaway
At the end of the day, there's no single correct answer to how spider man brand new day should rank against the rest of the franchise — only the answer that's true for you. Whether you're loyal to the Raimi trilogy, still defending Garfield, or fully on board with Holland's more mature turn, your ranking says something real about what you want from a Spider-Man story. Stop debating in the comments and build the list that's actually yours. Head over and create your own Spider-Man tier list in a couple of minutes — then come back and tell us where Brand New Day really landed for you.